Last updated: May 29, 2026

Cherry Picked Auto Parts is a local vehicle recycling yard located at 5650 N Detroit Ave, Toledo, OH, 43612. According to public business records and Google Maps data, it operates with a Google Customer Rating of 4.1 out of 5 stars based on 453 reviews. Many customers appreciate their selection of used OEM parts and fair pricing, though some reviews mention occasional wait times during busy periods.
Cherry Picked Auto Parts serves the Toledo, OH metropolitan area and surrounding towns. Their towing services for purchasing junk cars typically cover a broad radius around their North Detroit Avenue location, reaching communities within Lucas County and neighboring areas.
Based on the available customer feedback, Cherry Picked Auto Parts generally receives good marks for its range of available parts and the helpfulness of its staff. Patrons frequently comment on the ability to find specific OEM parts at a fraction of new retail cost. While the overall experience is positive, a few reviews indicate that customers might encounter short waits, particularly on weekends when the yard sees increased activity.
Cherry Picked Auto Parts provides a full-service experience for parts sourcing. Customers can inquire about specific parts, and the yard staff will retrieve them from the inventory. Core charge refunds are typically available for eligible parts returned within a specified timeframe. Cherry Picked Auto Parts operates on Sundays from 10:00 AM to 4:00 PM and is closed on Thursdays. For other weekday hours and payment methods, it is advisable to contact the yard directly.
Lot Advisory: Customers are advised to call ahead for parts availability and current operating hours. Bring a list of needed parts to help staff locate items quickly. Inquire about any return or exchange policies when purchasing parts.
| Property | Details |
|---|---|
| Address | 5650 N Detroit Ave, Toledo, OH, 43612 |
| Direct Phone | (419) 724-5503 |
| Operating Region | Sourced from Toledo, OH and neighboring towns |
| Part Source | Cost | Fitment & Quality | Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|
| Used OEM (Cherry Picked Auto Parts) | $$ (Very Low) | Perfect — Original factory fitment. | Exchange options may vary. |
| New Aftermarket | $$$ (Medium) | Good — Minor modifications might be needed. | 1 to 3 years. |
| OEM Dealer New | $$$$ (Highest) | Perfect — Original factory spec. | 12 months. |
Cherry Picked Auto Parts operates as a full-service salvage yard. You can inquire about specific parts needed, and their team will assist in locating and retrieving the items from their inventory. It is recommended to call ahead for parts availability.
Does Cherry Picked Auto Parts buy junk cars?Yes, Cherry Picked Auto Parts purchases junk cars and end-of-life vehicles. They offer local towing services to pick up vehicles and can assist with the necessary paperwork for transfer of ownership. Contact them directly for a cash quote on your vehicle.
What is the warranty policy for used parts?Warranty policies for used parts can vary. Generally, Cherry Picked Auto Parts offers exchange options for certain parts, often within a limited timeframe. It is best to confirm the specific warranty or return policy for your purchase at the time of sale to understand the terms for parts exchange or core charge refunds.
Find other salvage suppliers in our nationwide auto scrap yard directory.
4.4
Based on 1,344 Google reviews
Chris Huber
2 months ago
This place was not on my radar until recently. Being the Owner of a small business (HubesHub) that relies on self pull salvage yards, I was pleasantly surprised. I always talk about staff when reviewing, it's important to me. Slam dunk, great staff. Very friendly and helpful. The kind that brings a smile to your face when you arrive there. Let's talk vehicles. Great, volume and variety of import and domestic vehicles. HUGE pickup truck/Suv section. Prices are great with sign up for a free membership that gains points that equal $$$ off future purchases. That's not all gang. They regularly have 35-40% sales 😳 That's right, totally bananas. Christmas in February was 2/5 this year. I try to be objective in my reviews so I have to point out what could be improved. I think my only complaint would be the rows not being cleaned up. Can be difficult to get to traverse, but manageable. Check this place out and F franchises like PAP and PYP. Their prices are ridiculous. Makes me appreciate even more the places like UPRP. Great job guys, see you Sunday for 35% off. Thanks again-Hubes
Tavon Allen
11 months ago
Get flatbed shipping or commercial towing quotes directly matching this yard.
5846 N Detroit Ave, Toledo, OH, 43612
6193 Hagman Rd, Toledo, OH, 43612
1463 N Michigan St, Toledo, OH, 43604
I had the absolute pleasure of being helped by Nikki at U-Pull-R-Parts in Toledo, and I can’t say enough good things about her! From the moment I walked in, her warm smile and welcoming personality made the whole experience so much better …
Madisyn Sieloff
2 months ago
Had a very easy and smooth time getting rid of my junk car. Put in a quote online, received an email offer within a day, & my car was picked up outside my house the next day. Didn’t have any hiccups getting the money for it, all in all happy with my time and happy I went thru them.
Danielle
6 months ago
I was in an accident on the highway at almost 6 pm, it was my first accident and I was very shaken. I had no time to decide what to do or where to go, I had to get my totaled car off the highway. I started to call places (all within their business hours) one didn’t answer and the next told me it was just too late. U-Pick not only answered but said I could tow and drop my car even if they weren’t still open. They answered all my questions with patience and kindness even though I know it was closing time. I came in the next morning to complete the sale of my car and dealt with a woman who was so kind and sincere, on a day where I was so emotional I couldn’t have asked for a nicer person. Out of an overall scary and hard experience u-pick made that time just a little bit easier, and I greatly appreciate it. Thank you again!
Dylan Aldrich
3 months ago
Everyone I dealt with is super nice and made the process extremely tasteful
Cave Droll
4 months ago
Over the last few years sense Cherry Picked sold out this yard has gotten worse and worse and now its at a head you go in on a 50% off day and still end up paying what the website says is the full price for something after all of the random …
Yolanda Hannah
8 months ago
$I'm here at you pull your parts with Nikki and she did a wonderful job helping me out her customer service was extraordinary and my experience was the same. She definitely deserves a raise she's always smiling happy willing to help and she should definitely be manager. 10 plus Stars wish I could have gave a 10 but unfortunately the Max was 5.
John Irlam
6 months ago
They gave me a great price for my town and country, and the tow truck driver was able to come earlier than the scheduled time. I love this place.
MudMade Music419
7 months ago
The cashier Jay was very informative and professional he even let me in during closing time which he didn't have to let me do I definitely recommend these guys the parts was high Quality as well!
Paul Black
Edited 3 months ago
Great used parts for a great price. Wonderful inventory, old,new, domestic and foreign. Top dollar pricing on buying used, junk, salvage or no longer road worthy vehicles.